Streamlining the Payroll Experience

I collaborated with the Director of Product Management and led another designer to streamline the backstage payroll process across multiple departments while reimagining the frontstage customer experience. We presented the work to the CFO and SVPs, securing funding for initiatives that reduced the payroll timeline.

Project
End-to-End

Role
Design Lead

Year
2018-2019

Scope
Service Design
System Design
User Research

THE ASK

Redesign the cross-departmental payroll journey by identifying opportunities to ‘buy’ time across cross-department workflows so as to reduce it by 1 day to match competitor timelines.

BUSINESS CONTEXT

We were working with a $3 billion Professional Employment Organization (PEO) that allows businesses to outsource their human resources such as payroll via co-employment. Their system was supporting around 300,000 payrolls.

Their payroll was taking 1 day longer than competitors to process payroll as it was more conservative in its approach to financial risk. The issue was becoming problematic as it was being brought up by current customers and by prospects in sales calls.

We were tasked to study the implications of taking on more risk and identify areas across departments to find opportunities to ‘buy’ time.

Outcomes

The CFO approved most of our recommendations. A committee was formed with representatives from the departments we interviewed, and they used our deliverables to accelerate their work. Through ongoing collaboration with this committee, we reduced the payroll timeline by approximately one day.

TIMELINE REDUCTION

28%

reduction in the payroll timeline from submission to delivery of paycheck

CUSTOMER RATING

+37%

increase in customer rating of payroll process 3 months after implementation

TEAM ALIGNMENT

19

internal stakeholders across 9 departments to co-create the future

BEHAVIORAL ANALYTICS

-24%

reduction in rework rate of payroll due to reduced errors and dependencies

1 Employee Perspective
2 Customer Perspective
3 Framing the Vision
4 Presenting to the CFO

We interviewed employees across Payroll, Treasury, Client Services, and Info Tech to map the backstage operations supporting the customer experience. This revealed challenges causing delays and opportunities to increase speed by strategically taking on calculated financial risk

Process Flows caused Unnecessary Work

From interviews that I conducted, I learned practices that were borne out of good intentions for the customer had lasting effects on other teams such as added work or undoing work that were done.

I brought these teams together to figure out better sequencing for some of these bottlenecks or find ways to enable it to happen behind the scenes so that customers’ expectations are managed.

Audits pause payroll for supervisor review and are helpful during onboarding when errors are more likely. However, they were continuing unnecessarily afterward, causing delays. We moved them behind the scenes to prevent customers from expecting audits as standard practice.

Task sequencing across teams and departments lacked coordination, leading to redundant work. We collaborated across teams to design clear handoff points between workflows, ensuring upstream actions informed downstream processes and eliminated duplicative effort.

Low-Risk Practices reduced Competitiveness

Doing payroll for a PEO was unique as they were liable for unfunded payrolls where they would have to cover the cost if customers did not have the required funds.

However, the teams were also using outdated practices or thresholds to determine risk. I learned that they were open to moving to more risky funding methods but needed ways to make the tracking easier.

The funding method for low-risk reverse fund wire (RFW) was determined by payroll size, but the team was using outdated thresholds that hadn’t kept pace with rising payroll amounts over the years.

The Cash Management team knew their reluctance to move to ACH was causing delays, but they requested for processes and tools to track and recover funds after payroll, similar to what competitors had.

Manual and Error-Prone Tools caused Delays

I saw that teams lacked dedicated tools and were still using spreadsheets manually copied from multiple sources. This increased the chances of errors and forced them to spend significant time double or triple checking everything to ensure accuracy.

I advocated for digital tools in the vision especially for those that had cross-department dependencies and needs.

Teams creating the manual spreadsheets also struggled, pulling data from multiple sources and relying on email to share them. This often led to teams working from outdated files, causing errors and wasted time.

Different teams sent manual spreadsheets at varying intervals, forcing downstream teams to waste significant time and effort managing and manually reformatting the data to make it usable for their needs.

1 Employee Perspective
2 Customer Perspective

3 Framing the Vision
4 Presenting to the CFO

We documented the current payroll process through a service blueprint from the customer perspective to understand their emotional goals beyond just functional needs. This helped us identify key areas of friction and frustration in their front-stage experience.

Repetitive Tasks from Different Departments

From customers I interviewed, different payroll departments requested similar information from customers at different times, making customers feel like they were completing payroll multiple times .

I learned from customers that they saw payroll as a necessary chore, like doing laundry, and being forced to repeat this tedious process made the experience more frustrating. They were eager to learn ways to make the whole process easier.

Customers felt frustrated doing payroll multiple times as different departments requested similar info. I worked with those departments to consolidate requests and surface the info in the customer payroll tool, solving the issue now and preventing it in the future .

Payroll was not something that many of the customers actively thought about or had bandwidth to think of improving. They wished to learn best practices from their vendors or providers for customers similar to them and to be more efficient.

Improve Transparency for Trust Building

There were some areas of frustration from customers in the payroll process that dealt with miscommunication or feelings of mistrust due to the lower risk tolerance where customers felt like they were not trusted.

I looked for ways to improve transparency through communications and being a little more open on the payroll risk profile of the customers.

Customers had no visibility into internal activities after submitting payroll . Even when work progressed behind the scenes, customers felt like nothing was happening. I proposed automated updates to bridge this transparency gap to keep customers informed .

Due to the low risk-taking from the company where payroll would only get funded after receiving the customer’s funds, customers felt like they were not trusted or seen as risky even though their own bank saw them as a stable company with strong line of credit.

1 Employee Perspective
2 Customer Perspective
3 Framing the Vision
4 Presenting to the CFO

We translated the insights and learnings from customer and employee interviews into broader explorations of an improved payroll experience focused on its implication on timelines and processes.

Experience Principles to Align Teams

As this was a large project with many connected parts with many problems to solve, I focused on team alignment first by co-creating experience principles with the different departments on the desired future experience.

Articulating the Payroll Vision

I worked with the team to bring the experience principles to life through ideation workshops before refining and articulating them into a story as a north star. A visual designer assisted with creating the images and collaborated with another designer on the overall story and ideas.

Some ideas that highlight the Experience Principles are shown below.

Ongoing Risk Profile

Instead of only assessing risk at the start of the business relationship, I advocated for building each customer’s risk profile over time based on their actual behaviors, such as submitting payroll on time and funding on time.

This ongoing risk assessment approach would provide a more accurate and dynamic understanding of customer reliability.

Cash Management can easily track payroll statuses and maintain an ongoing risk profile for each customer . If customers have Non-Sufficient Funds (NSF) twice, they receive a warning the first time and lose the ability to use ACH for payroll after the second occurrence .

Single Customer View

Internal teams worked in silos, viewing customers only through their specific lens—new hires, terminations, or other isolated activities. This central place allowed teams to see the complete customer picture and understand how other teams’ tasks might impact their own work.

Team Workspace allows for a single source of truth of the customer where different teams can see each other’s involvement and timelines so as to know how their task impacts others or whether they should wait for another team.

1 Employee Perspective
2 Customer Perspective
3 Framing the Vision
4 Presenting to the CFO

This complex, multi-faceted solution required CFO approval. For the review, I condensed the problems and solutions into six life-sized Decision Posters that showcased tradeoffs and payoffs, timeline impacts, and sub-decisions. This enabled streamlined decision-making by highlighting risk and process implications at the right level of detail.

Summarized into 6 life sized decision posters

We printed these 6 decision posters and placed them on boards where I walked through and discussed these top 6 decisions with the CFO & SVPs.

These posters helped keep conversations at the right level of altitude with the appropriate next level of detail and action. I worked with a visual designer on layout but put in most of the content for the posters.

I simplified the complex and interconnected problems into top-level decisions with the left side for risk (tradeoff for red) for the company & customers, and the right side for reward (payoff for green) to have strong payoff and tradeoff discussions.

I highlighted easy comparisons between the current process and how each decision would impact the timeline, steps, improvements, and associated risks to clarify the impact on the process.

Learnings & Takeaways

This was a complex, cross-departmental project that required me to constantly figure out which problems were the real issues versus which were just symptoms of deeper problems. The scale and interconnected nature of everything demanded careful thinking about where to focus my efforts for the biggest impact.

It was also an invaluable experience working at the C-suite level. I learned to frame my work around strategic implications and trade-offs rather than design details, and to focus on business outcomes and calculated risks when presenting to executives.

I went on to design other applications in this HR space including open enrollment, employee onboarding, employer onboarding, and others.

Siloed Back-Stage Operations Multiply Front-Stage Friction

I learned that departmental fragmentation doesn’t just create inefficiency—it multiplies customer pain. When internal teams work in silos, customers experience the same task repeatedly, turning an already tedious process into a compounding source of frustration. The key insight was recognizing that organizational structure itself can inadvertently create duplicative customer burden, not just inefficiency.

Executive Stakeholder Communication Requires Strategic Altitude

I learned that executives really need to see risk and process implications at the appropriate level of detail without getting lost in granular workflow details. Tailoring my deliverables to zoom out and present strategic choices rather than operational minutiae was key to securing buy-in and moving the project forward.

Other Projects

Healthcare • 0–to–1 • Mobile/Service Design • B2B2C

Building the First Offering for a Health Platform for MS Patients

Data Storage • Dashboard • B2B

Unifying SMB Products into an Enterprise Storage Platform

Healthcare • 0-to-1 • Report Design • B2B

Creating the First Iteration of a Volumetric MRI Report in 6 weeks